Law College in Multan II Best Law College in Multan Best law college in multan
Biological Importance of DNA
Importance of DNA Analysis in Cases of sexual assault
Now the questions are:
list of Law colleges in multan
Article 164 of Qanoon-e-Shahadat Order, 1984 provides:
There is a listing of cases of the Superior Courts of law on
the point:
These reasons are listed hereunder:
Analysis of The Case Cited as 2016 SCMR 274 about The Admissibility of DNA Test:
The case was related to the kidnap for ransom then
Qatl-e-Amd of a 10/11 years old boy who was killed by the appellants of the
case for the rationale of raising hue and cries. After the disclosure by the
appellants the bones alleged to be of the deceased, Best Law College in Multan were recovered from the
crime spot and were sent to the Forensic lab , Lahore where an enquiry officer
of biology , University of Punjab, conducted the DNA test with the positive
result.
The prosecution had placed reliance on the next piece of evidence:
i. telephone date of two mobile phones
ii. The judicial confession of the appellants recorded by
the Magistrate
iii. the extra judicial confession made by one of the
appellants before one of the prosecution witnesses
iv. The recovery of bones (12 in number), clothes and
slippers of the deceased from the crime spot
v. The recovery of the cash Best Law College in Multan
vi. The recovery of Suzuki Mehran Car, which one of the
appellants had allegedly purchased from unknown seller, paying a number of the
ransom , and
vii. Positive results of the DNA test
The Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the crime is an
un-witnessed crime. the entire edifice of the prosecution case is based on
circumstantial evidence and recovery of the alleged incriminating articles. The
Hon’ble court rejected all the above listed evidence after recording its
detailed reasons for Best Law College in Multan each piece of evidence and relevant facts.
Only the DNA test report was positive but there are many doubts regarding the report which adversely affected its admissibility as discussed by the Hon’ble judges within the subsequent way:
• The bones were recovered after one month of the murder and
according to the well-known medico-legal jurist, MODI such like destruction of
the entire body of person , even of teenager isn't possible within two months
because variety of visceras made up of tough tissues and full skeleton of human
body remain in-tuned . during this case only scattered pieces of bones were
recovered and not full skeleton of human body , Best Law College in Multanwhich by itself is
unbelievable, being against the well-established and universally recognized
juristic view.
• Keeping in view the availability of section 510, Cr.P.C. whereunder, the report of biochemical expert (a biochemist) on DNA isn't covered thus, it's hospitable a big debate because under the above provision of law, specified experts reports, excluding the report of Best Law College in Multan above said expert, are made admissible. Hon’ble judges held that they are unable to hold the same as an admissible piece of evidence in absence of any sanction of law.
• to form sure the fair-play and transparency, the samples
within the laboratories from the parents (of Deceased) should are taken within
the presence of some independent authority kind of a Magistrate and also the
recovered sample from the crime scene within an equivalent because of dispel
the possibilities of fabrication of evidence through corrupt practices. Best Law College in Multan Transition
of the sample to the laboratory should have also been made during a secure and
secure manner, but all such safeguards were ignored within this case.
• Contamination of DNA sample is additionally a huge issue which attributes lesser evidential value to the report. within the recent past many scandals in USA, UK and other countries have surfaced where desired DNA test reports were procured by the investigator after contaminating the sample. Such contamination has also been reported in some cases while the samples remained within the laboratories. Many inquiries were persisted this issue and stringent law has been made by many nations to prevent the contamination of samples outside and inside the laboratories. Best Law College in Multan Proper procedure has been laid down for securing and punctiliously putting into parcel the suspected materials to correlate with the samples of the parents to work out paternity or maternity. Similarly, stringent check and procedure has been provided to avoid and stop cross contamination of the two samples because if both are available contact with each other then, Best Law College in Multan it'll give false positive appearance and thus the expert is thus misled. it is also been discovered that credentials of the various experts, claiming possessed of upper qualification during this particular field, were found fake which they were thus, away from service.
• the entire case of prosecution was supported
circumstantial evidence . The principle of law, consistently laid down by this
Court is, that different pieces of such evidence got to make one chain, an
unbroken one, where one end of it touches the body and thus the opposite the
neck of the accused. just just in case of any ape-man within the chain, Best Law College in Multan the
whole chain is broken and no conviction are often recorder in crimes entailing
execution . This principle is fully curious about the facts and circumstances
of this case. There are many links which are missing.
Due to the reasons discussed above intimately the Hon’ble
Supreme Court refused to award execution just on the thought of only one piece
of evidence i.e. DNA test during a situation when no other circumstantial
evidence was supporting the case of prosecution. Best Law College in Multan It doesn't appear from the
detailed analytical study of the whole case that the intention of Hon’ble
Judges was to declare DNA Test report an inadmissible piece of evidence.
Rather, the choice contains clear guidelines to be followed so on urge DNA
based evidence admissible within the court.
Suggestions:
Keeping in view these circumstances following suggestions
are being recommended for the aim of making the prosecution case stronger, to
punish the offender, for the effective administration of justice and to
eradicate the crime from Pakistan.
1. More labs with qualified experts and advanced equipment
should be established altogether the provinces and major cities of Pakistan Best Law College in Multan so
as that quick investigation could be possible to achieve the important culprit
and exonerate the suspects.
2. Government should confirm that the scientists and
officials concerning the forensic evidence must be protected and secured from
the external influence, threats, political influence, bribery, coercion and
intimidation.
3. There should be collaboration with other countries for this purpose. The scientists, enforcement officials and crime scene investigators should be sent to other countries to seek out out new techniques of performing experiments so as Best Law College in Multan that they could apply them in Pakistan so as to extract the truth from the physical evidence.
4. If forensic investigation including DNA analysis is
correctly conducted, the Courts must consider this type of evidence as an
important piece of evidence and must believe it so as that the Best Law College in Multan other criminals
would be able to realize that they could got to face the results if they commit
a criminal offense in future. Once the offender of a case is punished, nobody
would dare to commit such offence again.
5. Women Protection Centers should be extended throughout
the country a minimum of at each district. The centers should be established,
well equipped and consisting of a trained and skilled team including a lady
doctor, a prosecutor, a forensic scientist, a psychologist, an investigator and
therefore the other such persons who may confirm the protection and security of
such victims also because the middle .
6. DNA data base should be maintained for the speedy
investigation just just in case of any crime.
7. Necessary amendment within the respective laws particularly within the Qanoon-e-Shahadat Order, 1984 be made to make DNA test a conclusive proof of evidence so on eliminate the crime from the society.
Introduction
The Constitution of Pakistan 1973 has been drafted within
the time when the notice about environmental issues was at its emergence
globally. because the Constitution of Pakistan doesn't discuss environmental
rights as basic rights, the litigation related to environmental issues has been
called upon the Article 9 (Right to life) and Article 14 (Right to dignity of
man) of the Constitution along-with Article 184(3) [Public Interest litigation]
in Pakistan. A landmark precedent thereto is Shela Zia v. WAPDA,[1] during this
landmark judgment, the Supreme Court of Pakistan recognized the right to
hygienic and safe environment as fundamental Best Law College in Multanright of the residents of the
locality, where the installation of electromagnetic grid station was proposed
by WAPDA with none prior research and assessment. The Court also recognized the
precautionary principle[2] during this case while appointing the NESPAK as a
Commissioner to seem at , study and assess the adverse impacts, if any, of the
proposed action on the locality and lifelong of individuals .
After the Stockholm Conference 1972, Environmental Ministry was established in Pakistan. The Ministry was responsible for environmental legislation within the country. Under Environmental Ministry, Pakistan Environmental Ordinance was promulgated in 1983. After Pakistan’s participation within the world Summit in 1992 as leader of Group 77 Countries, the State committed many international environmental agreements and conventions. within an equivalent year, National Conservation Strategy was drafted. within subsequent year, National Environmental Quality Standards got shape. Then, in 1997 Pakistan Environmental Protection Act (PEPA) repealed the Pakistan Environmental Ordinance, 1983. The brief discussion of this journey is as under:
1. The National Conservation Strategy 1992:
The National
Conservation Strategy (NCS) approved by the govt. of Pakistan on 1st March 1992
elaborates the prevailing environmental problems within the country in
conjunction with steps to strengthen the institutions, setting the
implementation supervision system, providing the financial supports for this
system . The Eight five years development plan had to accommodate this
contemporary approach to ameliorate the prevailing system of environmental laws
within the country, with the availability of revision of existing law and
Best Law College in Multanestablishing the research institutes i-e sustainable development institute of
Pakistan for promotion of research regarding environmental matters. the notice
among people about environmental concerns was to be made through mass media,
according to National Conservation Strategy and National Action Plan,
concerning conspicuous fourteen projects which were to be undertaken i-e improved
biodiversity, better irrigation and agriculture system etc.[3]
2. Pakistan Environmental Protection Ordinance, 1983
Pakistan Environmental Protection Ordinance 1983 is that the legislation of that time when environment was a federal subject under the constitutional list. The Ordinance provided the provisions on the subject of federal environmental protection council, federal and provincial environmental protection agencies, penalties for violators and indemnities related to environmental matters etc. The Environmental Protection Council under this Ordinance was to be headed by the President of Pakistan, but after an amendment during this law in 1994, the Prime Minister of Pakistan or his nominee was made eligible to act as a md of this Council.
Majority of
provisions during this Ordinance were never implemented, as an example ,
according to a provision, environmental protection council was imagined to meet
biannually once a year , but actually , the council did never meet throughout
the lifetime of this law. because of non-implementation of this Ordinance
thanks to presence of some irregularities or vague provisions like powers of
environmental protection council, growing need in society about regulation of
the matters relating pollution and other environmental issues, this law was
repealed by a replacement law in 1997.
3. Pakistan Environmental Protection Act, 1997:
Pakistan
Environmental Protection Ordinance 1983 was repealed by Section 34 of the
Pakistan Environmental Protection Act 1997 (PEPA). it's 34 Sections and a
Schedule. The preamble of this Act states;
“An Act to provide
for the protection, conservation, rehabilitation and improvement of the
environment, for the prevention and control of pollution, and promotion of
sustainable development…”
PEPA, being a replacement law repealing the old one,[4] was intended to manage and implement the sustainable development techniques within the county beside NCS and NEQS. Pakistan Environmental Protection Council[5] was established with the Prime Minister of Pakistan as its head. Pakistan Environmental Protection Agency was established under this Act, Best Law College in Multan which delegated its powers to the provincial agencies who further delegated their powers to the divisional agencies.[6]
Pakistan Environmental Protection Agency established under
this Act[7] is responsible for the enforcement of environmental laws in
Pakistan. The Provincial environmental protection agencies are established
under section 8 of this Act. Provincial Sustainable Funds are established under
Section 9. Section 11 is about prohibition of certain discharges and emissions,
whereas, Section 12 provides for significance of IEE and EIA before initiation
of any project.
Section 17 enlists different penalties just just in case of violating the environmental stipulations under different provisions of this law i-e Sections 11, 12, 13, 16 and Sections 14 & 15. The penalties could even be within the type of fine and also imprisonment just just in case of violations under certain conditions. Section 18 illustrates the punishments, just just in case of violating the principles provided under this Act by the body corporate. Section 20 is regarding environmental tribunals established under this Act. Appeals from an impugned Order of the environmental tribunal could even be laid before the supreme court . Section 24 determines the jurisdiction of Environmental Magistrate, just just in case of any complaint by any agency , local council or an aggrieved person. Under Section 25, the Best Law College in Multan appeal against any order of Environmental Magistrate shall be laid before the Court of Session, whose decision shall be final during this behalf. Sections 31 and 33 are about making of rule and regulations respectively, for completing the aim of this Act.
Rules and regulations
Overall, the Act
promotes the participation of public within the decision-making process related
to different environmental issues, especially the Environmental Impact
Assessment (EIA) provision. Citizens aggrieved by any adverse environmental
impact, under this Act, may go the Environmental Tribunal. The Act also
promotes the Polluter Pays Principle by empowering the Environmental Protection
Agency to order the shutting down of industries or imposing fines on the
vehicles producing the emissions in access to the National Environmental
Quality Standards.
Schedule to the
Act[8] contains the list of International Conventions concerning which the
Federal or Provincial Governments have the powers to make rules. they go to not
be implemented in their true letter and spirit, unless such rules under them
are made by the Best Law College in Multan relevant governments in several jurisdictions of the country.
The Provincial Sustainable Development Fund Board (Procedure) Rules, 2001, The Environmental Sample Rules, 2001, The National Environmental Quality Standards (Self-Monitoring and Reporting by Industry) Rules, 2001, The Pollution Charge for Industry (Calculation and Collection) Rules, 2001, The Provincial Sustainable Development Fund (Utilization) Rules, 2003 are samples of Rules made under Section 31 of the PEPA 1997.
The Environmental
Tribunal Rules, 1999, The Pakistan Environmental Protection Agency Review of
Initial Environmental Examination and Environmental Impact Assessment
Regulations, 2000, BTS Regulations for Environmental Protection are a few of
regulations made under Section 33 of the PEPA 1997.
4. National Environmental Quality Standards (NEQS):
National
Environmental Quality Standards (NEQS) related to ambient air, beverage ,
noise, municipal and industrial liquid effluents and standards for industrial
gaseous emission are notified in Official Gazette of Pakistan under clause(c),
Sub-section (1) of Section 6 of PEPA 1997. NEQS sets the certain standards
under specific conditions about physical and chemical condition, and
composition of air, water and gases present within the environment. Best Law College in Multan The
foregoing standards about quality of beverage shows the buildup of arsenic and
lead quite prescribed World Health Organization (WHO) standards in Pakistan.[9]
5. Environmental Provisions in Pakistan code and Criminal Procedure Code:
The Environmental provisions within the Pakistan code 1860 are related to punishment of fouling water or public spring or reservoir, punishment for creating atmosphere noxious for health, punishment for negligent conduct with regard to poison , punishment for negligent conduct with regard to fire or combustible matter and punishment for negligent conduct with regard to explosive substance.[10]
Section 133 of
Criminal Procedure Code[11] deals with the notice of public nuisance by the
District or Divisional Magistrate and spending any conditional Order
accordingly. Section 144[12] deals with any written Order gone Divisional or
District Magistrate in perspective of Section 134. This Section is so wide that
closing down of any health-hazardous restaurant, factory or pharmacy etc. also
comes under its ambit.
6. Pakistan global global climate change Act, 2017
Pakistan global global climate change |temperature change"> global climate change |temperature change"> global climate change |temperature change"> global climate change Act 2017 is new law combating the climate change and implementing the strategies concerning sustainable development within the country. This law is an effort to implement the UNFCCC, Kyoto Protocol and Paris Agreement at domestic level. the worldwide global climate change Council, with the Prime Minister of Pakistan as its head, has been established thereunder including Chief Ministers of all Provinces and Environmental Protection and global global climate change Ministers, both at Federal and Provincial levels. Environmental Protection Authority is responsible for Best Law College in Multan implementation of the mitigation techniques under the Act. global global climate change Fund, established under the Act, is that the most source of financing the activities regarding global global climate change in Pakistan.
“Pakistan is ranked seventh among countries most affected by
and vulnerable to global global climate change disasters in spite of being
ranked 135th among the countries in global green house gases contribution.
Pakistan contributes only 0.8 in global greenhouse gasses.” said the Climate
Minister of Pakistan, Mr. Zahid Hamid.[13]
7. Policy on Controlling Smog, 2017 (Punjab)
the matter of smog is
gradually increasing once a year and causing health problems to citizens in
Pakistan. The province of Punjab is particularly affected by this issue. Punjab
government’s policy for controlling smog elaborates the reasons causing smog
within the Province of Punjab. Different activities are recommended by the
govt. for improving things like issuance of health advisory, issuance of
traffic advisory, shutting down of major smoke emitting industries, introducing
low carbon fuels, adoption of Euro-II standards for reduction of vehicular
emissions, better traffic management for reduction of vehicular emissions,
controlling burning of municipal waste and crop residue, creating woodlands
around major cities, road shoulders designed for deserter Earth, planned urban
and industrial development, greening of economic processes, regional
environmental agreements.[14]
However, this policy has faced criticism from the environmentalists and other members of civil society. They condemned the step of linking the smog phenomenon with India’s burning of rice crop stubble although the environmentalist found no concrete Best Law College in Multan evidence related to this cause. In fact, the EPA’s inability to remain a check on the air quality within the province could also be a serious explanation for smog, according to the critics.[15]
8. Billion Tree Tsunami by Khayber PakhtunKhwa Government:
the govt. of
KhayberPakhtunKhawa province in Pakistan took the green initiative for meeting
the Bonn Challenge to combat deforestation and restoration of degraded land.
during this respect, the govt. met its challenge to grow a billion trees within
the Province within the time span of two years. This step of provincial
government received admiration throughout the earth , especially by the
IUCN[16], who recognized the initiative as a pro-forestation Best Law College in Multan and
environmental-friendly break-through for combating the impacts of worldwide
global climate change and heating . It aimed toward fulfilling the Bonn Challenge
taken for restoring 350,000 hectares of forests and degraded land.[17]
Wildlife Rules, Fisheries Act and Rules, The Forest Act 1927 are another pieces of legislations on the subject of conservation of safe and clean environment, balanced ecology and biodiversity of the planet within the jurisdiction of Pakistan.
Pakistan’s Participation & Compliance to International Accords:
The Multilateral
Environmental Agreements (MEAs) during which Pakistan participated and ratified
include; Ramsar Convention on Wetlands 1971,[18] Convention on Migratory
Species 1971,[19] Convention on International trade species (CITES) 1973,[20]
Convention on the law of Seas 1982,[21] Vienna Convention on the Protection of
ozonosphere 1989,[22] Montreal Protocol on ozonosphere Depleting Substances
1989,[23] Basal Convention on the control of Trans-boundary Movement of
Hazardous Wastes 1992,[24] Convention on Biological Diversity 1992,[25] United
Nations Convention to Combat Desertification 1994,[26] United Nations Convention
on global global climate change 1992,[27] Kyoto Protocol to UNFCCC 1997,[28]
Rotterdam Convention on Prior consent (PIC) surely Hazardous Chemicals and
Pesticides 1999,[29] Cartagena Protocol on Bio-safety to CBD 2001[30] and
Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs) 2001.[31]
Majority of these Conventions are annexed to the Schedule of Pakistan Environmental Protection Act 1997, under which the Federal or Provincial governments have powers to make rules for implementation of these Conventions, within the domain of national system in Pakistan.
Paris Accord COP 21
in November, 2015 could also be a landmark global initiative for combating
global global climate change and heating . As Pakistan is one of the first ten
countries, who will suffer most by heating , she signed this agreement at the
first day of its opening for signature. And Pakistan also ratified this
historic agreement in November, 2016 from its parliament.[32] Integration of
this accord at national level in Pakistan has also been incorporated through
Pakistan global global climate change Act, 2017.
Role of Judiciary:
Being within the regime of Common system Countries, the adversarial system is followed in Pakistan generally. But just just in case of environmental field, the trend of “Public Interest Litigation”[33] supported “Inquisitorial Legal System” has replaced this tradition. the most reason of this approach is that the finality clause within the Pakistan Environmental Protection Act 1997, under which at the trial stage, the proceedings about environmental matters Best Law College in Multan cannot be delivered to the court of law. As an alternate , however, the appeals from Environmental Tribunals are made to the High Courts. another reason is that the aspect of locus standi, only an aggrieved person can initiate the action under the Act.[34] thanks to this fact, the majority of environmental cases come under the realm of Public Interest Litigation (PIL) in Pakistan. as an example , the landmark case of this sequence, establishing the right to safe environment through right to life and right to dignity of man i-e Shela Zia v WAPDA, during which Obiter Dicta states as follows;
“The word life has not been defined within the Constitution
but it doesn't suggest nor can it's restricted only to the vegetative or animal
life or mere existence Best Law College in Multan from conception to death. Life includes all such
amenities or facilities, which a private during a free country is entitled to
enjoy with dignity, legally and constitutionally.”[35]
In Tanvir Arif vs.
Federation of Pakistan, the petitioner filed a writ petition against the letter
of Chief Protocol of the Ministry Foreign Affairs, addressed to the Chief
Secretary , for allocating the planet for the hunt of Houbara Bustard in
violation of Section 7 of The Sindh Wildlife Protection Ordinance 1972. The
Sindh supreme court declared this act in breach of the prevailing law on the
problem , thus, warned the respondent for not doing any such thing in
future.[36]
PIL under Article 184(3)[37] also involves the suomotu actions taken by the judiciary because it's removed the procedural hindrances within the way of adversarial system , by replacing it with inquisitorial one, within the cases of public importance involving public trust Doctrine. “The Lahore Canal Road Case”[38] is additionally a prominent example of this aspect, which may be discussed elsewhere during this chapter.
Judicial Supremecy
The Supreme Court
appointed a commission in 1994, within the case of General Secretary, Pakistan
Salt Mines Labour Union (CBA), Khewara v. Directors, Industries and Mineral
Development, Punjab, Lahore,[39] so on research the illegal extensive mining by
leasing out the coalpit lease in water catchment area , which caused trouble
also as violated the right of unpolluted water of residents and mine workers of
Jhelum. during this case, after the findings of Commission, that was given vast
powers under Order XXVI of the Civil Procedure Code, Best Law College in Multan the Court ordered the
shifting of mouth of Mine number 27A by the Punjab Coal Company within four
months to make sure that there is no contamination of the water reservoir
thanks to any spill over, debris or the opposite pollution. This case was also
initiated within the general public interest under Article 184(3) and thus the
top of Commission, Dr. Pervez Hassan, used his earlier knowledge and knowledge
of Shela Zia case for handling this hazardous issue of public importance that
was compelling the people of that area to compromise their health by
consumption of sub-standard water.
In Ms. Imrana Tiwana et al. v. LDA through its DG,[40] the Signal Free Corridor at Jail Road Lahore was challenged because no EIA was completed beforehand, and there have been many procedural irregularities acknowledged by the petitioner. There was no government performing at that point and therefore the Provincial Govt. conducted this project through Lahore Development Authority (LDA) that was a violation of procedural aspects. it had been challenged within the Lahore supreme court , where the interim order of injunction was passed, after the work was done almost halfway and a price of 60million rupees had already been incurred by that point . Hence, the ultimate Order of the Lahore supreme court was challenged within the Supreme Court of Pakistan, by different petitioners.
The Supreme Court allowed this project, because there was no objection as reference to EIA within the final Order of supreme court , seeing that it had been done after the interim Order of supreme court . the sole objection about this project was valid that it had been done through LDA rather than Lahore Metropolitan Corporation, which had to figure under any Government authority. Article 140A of the Constitution Pakistan requires that this sort of projects should be Best Law College in Multan done by the government authority or by the Provincial Government after obtaining the consent by government . Therefore, just in case of absence of government agency i-e Lahore Metropolitan Corporation, the Provincial Government is required by the Constitution to determine the local governments and devolve them the administration powers, which might make them to urge such projects done.
So, signal free corridor was allowed to finish by the Supreme Court of Pakistan, by setting aside the impugned Order of Lahore supreme court giving rise to a busy local governments election procedures. Some conditions of creating pathways and other facilities for the pedestrians, like crossover and passes at the interval of 1 kilo meter or less, were also made compulsory within the final project approval by the court . In Young Doctors Association of Pakistan et al. v. Government of Pakistan et al. ,[41] the development of signal free junction at Azadi Chowk Lahore was objected due to destruction, demolition and acquisition of area of two Kanals and 11 Marlas of Lady Willingdon Hospital, Lahore. during this petition, the objections about lack of due diligence of environmental protection Act 1997 in respect of conducting of appropriate EIA of the project, were raised by the Petitioners.
the proper to life in Constitution of Pakistan in its extended meaning, on protect the proper of health of the citizens of Pakistan was also raised, because it was also against the sustainable development provisions under Environmental Protection Act. on the opposite hand, proposed demolition of the some a part of building of the hospital appeared to be the violation of the rights of patients, doctors and therefore the residents of hospital accommodation. thanks to the Best Law College in Multan evidences provided by the respondents, the Court held that the reconstruction of the demolished a part of "> a part of building within 45 days is additionally a compulsory part of this project. The Court asked the respondents to supply the report of this aspect, after completion of an equivalent within seven weeks. Further, held that the sustainable development under URBAN 21 Berlin Conference,[42] which explained the newest definition of sustainable development, consistent with which the project in hand is in compliance with the sustainable development, because it was an honest twist for this and future benefits of the citizens without compromising the requirements of future generations. Thus, the Court allowed this project.
In Lahore Conservation Society case,[43] the petitioners raised the purpose that due to the development of Lahore Kalma Chowk flyover, there would be cutting of an outsized number of trees, as a results of which the sweetness of site would go dim. Also, it'll be health hazardous for the people of that area, both after and through the development of the aforementioned flyover. The Lahore supreme court held that it's need of the hour to construct an equivalent , due to huge holdup within the area, especially, when the ambulances aren't ready to make their answers during the height hours. The petitioner public interest litigation, nevertheless, the Court said it had been a factual controversy because the construction of flyover is within the Best Law College in Multan favour of public rather than its non-construction. The Court further elaborated that if any hurdle is faced by public within the present for obtaining any future gain, then it's not against the general public interest. To the extent of some points regarding cutting of trees, the Court relied upon the instance of Shalamar Flyover and Underpass, before construction of which tons of trees were hamper but they were re-planted after its construction for invigorating the sweetness of the location . Hence, the petition was dismissed by the Court concerned.
In Islamuddin v.
Ghulam Muhammad, the Supreme Court of Pakistan held that the noise from a
workshop may be a common nuisance . The Court declared that the noise either
being made during the lawful course of action, if it's a explanation for
discomfort for peaceful exercise of the proper to lifetime of the encompassing
community, should be avoided as falling within the category the general public nuisance.[44]
In Lahore Metro Orange Line Train Case, a writ was filed within the Lahore supreme court for the protection of 11 historical sites under Special Premises (Preservation) Ordinance 1985 and Antiquity Act 1975. The supreme court ordered the stay of construction work within 200 meters radius of those sites. And in Appeal against this order by the relevant State agencies, the Supreme Court of Pakistan ordered to resume the development on the sites under 31 conditions after detailed observation of the matter. The conditions are regarding preservation of web sites of archaeological importance from any damage during the development and operation of the Metro Orange Line Train within the city of Lahore.[45]
Green Benches:
As an outcome of
Bhurban Declaration 2012 entitled “A Common Vision on Environment for the South
Asian Judiciaries” during South Asian Conference[46] on Environmental Justice
under the patronage of the Supreme Court of Pakistan, the judge of Supreme
Court ordered establishing the green benches in the least High Courts
along-with the Supreme Court of Pakistan. The intention of such move was to
listen to the environment related writs and appeals at higher courts by the
dedicated single also division benches. This initiative is far appreciated
because the environmental tribunals under environmental protection agencies
were mostly inefficient in Best Law College in Multan concluding the cases associated with environmental
concerns. Transfer of environmental cases pending at tribunal levels also are a
neighborhood of the initiative as declared by the relevant Green Benches
afterward .[47] Moreover, at sub-division level all senior civil judges cum
judicial magistrate’s courts have also declared as green courts under this
initiative.
AsgharLeghari v. Federation of Pakistan[48] is another milestone case within the history of Green Bench of Lahore supreme court . Honorable Justice Syed Mansoor Ali Shah took action on the PIL of a farmer AsgharLeghari, who pleaded that in-spite of the severe threat of global climate change related disaster; the Authorities in Pakistan have did not implement the global climate change Policy 2012 and Framework for implementation of global climate change Policy (2014-2030). the govt has did not meet its own deadlines during this regard. Justice Shah summoned all the relevant authorities within the court and ordered them to appoint focal person of every departments about implementation of global climate change policies. He also appointed global climate change Commission in his landmark judgement for observation of authorities’ relevant action for fulfillment of framework action on the difficulty by the top of the year 2015. The Green Bench divulged as follows:
“[f]or Pakistan,
global climate change is not any longer a foreign threat-we are already feeling
and experiencing its impacts across the country and therefore the region. The
country experienced devastating floods during the last three years. These
changes accompany far reaching consequences and real economic costs.” [49]
Role of NGO’s:
Successful
integration of Public interest litigation in environmental law is an upshot of
fruitful efforts of the many non-governmental organizations also as public
spirited individuals. Such results are proved of getting far-reaching impacts
on the regime of environmental law within the countries having common legal
systems i-e Pakistan and India. Best Law College in Multan The role of NGO’s about environment has also
been highlighted within the NCS.[50] The role played by NGO’s within the
country is providing the general environmental awareness at grass root level
within the country alongside working within the other umbrella fields like
agriculture, livestock, poultry, social control , forestation initiatives etc.
within the case of “Cutting of Trees for Canal Widening Project Lahore”[51] an idea to widen the 14 kilo meters long stretch of Lahore canal road was announced. But the suo motu notice of the Supreme Court of Pakistan came for highlight within the importance of green belt on the side of the canal road Lahore because it may be a charitable trust . So, the court appointed a mediator, who made a Committee for resolving the difficulty peacefully. The Committee had to supply the rules for smooth running of the project along-with taking into consideration the adverse environmental impacts of cutting of trees during widening the road. Basically, this issue came into lime light due to an Environmental NGO, Lahore Bachao Tehreek (LBT), which condemned the choice of cutting of trees including other pressure groups and environmentalists within the country. The reaction was against the cutting of trees within the green belt beside the Lahore Canal, which might further pollute the city’s environment within the presence of existing deficiency of plantation and forestation within the country, far below than the recommended level for clean, healthy and unpolluted environment.
The Committee made by
mediator reached at consensus with reference to eighteen recommendations to
preserve the sustainability of the heritage of Lahore Canal along-with the
event . These recommendations were submitted to the Supreme Court of Pakistan
on 14th May, 2011. The recommendations were supported by the acceptable
reasoning for resolve the dispute of charitable trust Doctrine. The Committee
didn't give consent to widen the entire canal road, however, it only
recommended the widening by 3.25 kilo meters, Best Law College in Multan for cover the natural resources
of environment as a charitable trust . Finally, the Court allowed the
prolongation of the project on the idea of those recommendations about widening
the canal road within the limited capacity, on the condition of cutting of the
minimum possible number of trees on the green belt alongside the canal. Also,
the Punjab government vowed to exchange the each hamper tree with plantation of
100 mature trees after completion of the project.[52]
To reiterate, the journey from ‘nothing’ to ‘something’ within the field of environmental law has been covered gradually in Pakistan. Since the time of NCS, the trend of policy-making on the topic of environment was started and afterward , policy about different aspects of environment has been formulated. After 1985 Ordinance on the Environment, an enormous gap existed, both in legislation and implementation during this field within the country. The 18th Constitutional Amendment and PEPA 1997 broke the ice by giving rise provincial legislations and rules and regulations under them on the topic . Judiciary, NGO’s and other pressure groups of conscious and enlightened citizens also played their role for drafting the map of this field of law within the history of Pakistan
The international watchdog against concealment and terrorism
financing, FATF, has put Pakistan on ‘Grey List’ in June, 2018. It is
Pakistan is not the member of FATF but being the member of APG, it's bound to follow the recommendations of FATF. Pakistan has already been on the Grey List from 2012 to 2015. Pakistan has also been on the Blacklist years before 2015 when it got out of the Grey List. Pakistan had also to face strict sanctions within the year 1998 because of nuclear experiments.
After being placed on the Grey List, Pakistan was issued 27
guidelines by FATF to manage concealment and counter terrorism financing during
a period of 15 months. Pakistan has succeeded to suits almost 21 of these
implications. India is strongly opposing Pakistan and is trying to convince
FATF to place it in blacklist.
Pakistan is struggling hard to urge out of grey list till FATF’s next meeting by overcoming its strategic deficiencies. If Pakistan succeeds in getting out of Grey List, the doors of foreign investment would open for it and it'd be able to procure loans and financial aids from IMF, ADB and World Banks. India has always been found to be determined to pin down Pakistan towards “blacklist”.
It was the results of Pakistan’s efforts to combat ML and
Terrorism that the FATF President Marcus Pleyer announced at a virtual
conference held after the body’s three-day plenary session that Pakistan would
keep it up its place on “grey-list” until February, 2021. Pakistan has six more
implications left to be fulfilled.
FATF Overview: Structure, Members, Purpose, Objective, Functioning and Procedure
FATF is that the Financial Action Task Force which was
established in 1989 in Paris by the Group of seven (G7). it's an
inter-governmental body with 39 members including 37 jurisdictions and a few of
organizations (the Gulf Cooperation Council and thus the ecu Commission). These
members are at the core of combating concealment and terrorist financing. Best Law College in Multan There
are also 31 Associate Members of FATF which are the numerous international and
regional organizations and act as Observers of FATF. They also participate
within the working of FATF to satisfy its objectives.[1]
Initially FATF was acknowledged to affect the drug problems and concealment but after 9/11 incident, counter terrorism financing was also added in its objectives. to start out with, in 1990 there are 40 recommendations of FATF to tackle money related issues but after extending its working to CFT, it added 8 Special Recommendations, while the 9th one was added in 2004.[2]
FATF could also be a policy-making also as enforcement body.
FATF features a correct procedure for:
• Monitoring countries efforts in ensuring implementation of
FATF Recommendations
• Reviewing concealment and terrorist financing techniques
and thus the counter-measures
• Promoting the adoption and implementation of these
Recommendations throughout the earth
FATF implements its Recommendations through the tactic of
mutual country evaluation whereby it observes the compliance of the country to
those international standards. This process is supplemented by the assessment
conducted by FSRBs, the IMF and / Best Law College in Multan or International Bank for Reconstruction and Development
concerning AML / CFT efforts of the state. Following the assessment, FATF may
put any country in
“Black list” if the country is found supporting terror
funding and concealment activities also mentioned as list of NCCTs; or
“Grey List” if any country is found to be at higher risk of money laundering and terror financing but commits to work with FATF by planning and addressing their deficiencies
Major causes for putting Pakistan
In June, 2018, during the proceedings of FATF meeting, the
motion was raised for diplomatic isolation of Pakistan and entering its name on
the Grey List. Opposition was so strong that even the foreign allies China and
Saudi Arabia couldn't support Pakistan. FATF didn't specifically mentioned the
reasons for doing so but few reasons were quite clear which are as under:
1. Pakistan was alleged for being involved in concealment
because of the then weak political will against evasion , tax invasion and
corruption. it had been also because of the several scandals revealed against
politicians e.g. Ashiyana Housing Scheme Scandal, Best Law College in Multan Benami Accounts Scandal,
Panama Paper Case, Hudaybia steelworks Case etc. because of friendly opposition
and agreement of sheltering on alternate terms of state exploited things . plea
bargain also facilitated the corrupt politicians by providing them the way to
flee .
2. Allegations raised by India and US against Pakistan for supporting terrorist organizations also pressurized FATF to feature its name within the Grey List. India alleged Pakistan for being involved in Pulwama Attacks raised strong voice against it stressing to impose sanctions thereon . Moreover the allegations of drug trafficking and racketeering also added up to lower the image of Pakistan.
3. another reason is that the inefficiency of various state
institutions and their lack of collaboration and cooperation in handling such
matters including FBR, NAB, FIA and ANF. In such situation they're unable to
follow and implement National Action Plan. It increases the sense of lawlessness
and insecurity among the foreign investors.
4. Various international reports rank Pakistan at a very
poor level with regard to concealment . A Swiss Group, Basel Institute on
Governance ranked Pakistan as 46th country among 146, in its report of 2017,
for being involved in concealment . Such reports also highlight the problems of
the system which resulted into such degradation.
5. Judiciary is additionally unable to play its role
resulting into the impression that there is no rule of law within the country.
it is also distorting the image of Pakistan and shattering the arrogance of
foreign investors. Best Law College in Multan Enforced disappearance of people has also been a stain on
human rights record of Pakistan.
6. Bureaucracy of Pakistan is additionally not transparent, which is additionally responsible in aggravating things . Many of the high ranked officials are usually involved in such offences and are a supporting hand of the politicians. it is also the rationale for country’s worst situation about concealment .
7. Parallel, informal banking system and existence of hundi
and hawala business are also one of the reasons for putting Pakistan on Grey
List. Weak banking system of Pakistan with faulty laws, poor implementation,
lack of proper planning and formulation of strategies all contribute during
this scenario.
8. Anti-Money laundering Laws and Anti-Terrorism Laws are
highly insufficient with several loopholes and lacunas leaving gaps for the
offenders to escape . These laws are being amended for years to include basic
provisions to bring the offender under the ambit of law. Available laws aren't
being effectively implemented because of insufficiency of resources, Best Law College in Multan structural
deficiencies, lack of professional competencies and departmental corruptions.
9. Media also plays its role by creating hypes and adding
spices to the news for the aim of their rating and breaking exclusive news.
They broadcast news without prior verification. Media showed its
irresponsibility when Pakistan was placed on the grey list by breaking the news
that Pakistan has been blacklisted by FATF. afterward the news was denied but,
till then it had been circulated all around the world. Likewise, media reports
every matter during a really fanciful manner and adversely affects the image of
Pakistan by portraying the wrong image regarding internal affairs of the
country.
10. one more reason was the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor which wasn't tolerated by India and US. The pressure to include the name of Pakistan in Grey List was also built for the rationale to destabilize Pakistan economically. In such situation Pakistan possesses to borrow money from other countries which may not be ready for this. Best Law College in Multan Ultimately Pakistan would have no other option except to request IMF for help. If such situation arrives Pakistan would wish to share its complete details of foreign funding including CPEC which has been kept secret so far .
Efforts by Pakistan in getting out of Grey-List
After being added within the grey list of FATF, Pakistan was
given 27 points agenda for countering ML and TF. To suits these points is that
the requisite to be shielded from blacklist. After restless struggle, Pakistan
has been successful in meeting with only 21 out of 27 points of the agenda.
During its meeting persisted 19-21 of February, 2020, in
Paris, FATF expressed its full satisfaction about the efforts of Pakistan
against concealment and terrorism financing particularly within the subsequent
areas:[3]
• NACTA website activation with complete access to the
proscribed persons
• in conjunction with continuous updates
• Introduction of ‘Know Your Customers’ policy by the
depository financial organization of Pakistan and thus the biometric
verification system of accounts
• Dissemination of reverse feedback and intelligence reports
by enforcement agencies to the SBP and Financial Monitoring Unit
• Risk assessment to cash smuggling specifically Best Law College in Multan with
reference to terrorist financing
• Strengthening Customs control throughout the country
• Effective utilization of domestic agencies against
terrorist financing
• Application of regulatory framework of the SBP for private
banking system
• Investigation mechanism and awareness campaign to all or any or any stakeholders regarding terror financing
The journey of improvement and struggle to clear the image
of Pakistan at International forum wasn't ended here. Pakistan has had to run
faster to understand the remaining targets by subsequent meeting of FATA.
Further efforts made by Pakistan in combating concealment and terrorism
financing are as under:
Validations
Various laws are introduced regarding the issues . it is
also been tried to urge obviate loopholes in various existing laws through
amendments. These laws include Anti-Money Laundering Act, 2010, Anti-Terrorist
Act, 1997, Protection of Economic Reforms Act, 1992, Payment System and
Electronic Fraud Transfer Act, 2007, Anti-Money Laundering and Counter
Financing Terrorism Regulations, 2018 etc.[4][5]
In April 2015, the sales tax Act and Federal Excise Duties
were amended to feature predicate offences. trading and market manipulation
were added as predicate offences in sales tax Act. Necessary amendments in tax
Ordinance, 2001 were also added regarding evasion and concealment of income.[6]
Financial Monitoring Unit (FMU) was established which in
conjunction with FBR has also played a stimulating role in improving system ,
bumping in exchange reserves and reducing illegal outflow of money .[7]
FBR is observing the affairs of NPOs and INPOs Best Law College in Multan on their
alleged involvement in ML and TF activities. FBR has traced out about 10,000
people involving concealment .[8]
Efforts of state cannot be ignored in curbing the offences including concealment . During his fight against corruption and evasion state has taken effective measures.
it had been because of his efforts that nominated
politician of the country who had lack political will at their times against
such offences, had to surrender before the law. Role of NAB is additionally
appreciable during this regard in revealing cases involving massive corruption.
it is a matter of undeniable fact that the govt. has been
fighting against ML and TF since long, even before demanded intrinsically by
the FATF. It conducted various operations to counter terrorism including
Zarb-e-Azb and Rad-ul-Fasad at the worth of quite 70,000 lives of civilians and
security personnel, resultantly cracking down about 20,000 terrorists.[9]
imprisoments
Pakistan also took action against UN declared terrorist
organizations JeM, LeT, JuD and FIF in counter terrorism efforts by banning
them which was also among the recommendations of the FATF. The arrest and
sentencing of Hafiz Saeed has also helped Pakistan Best Law College in Multan to urge better standing at
international level.[10]Seeking to wriggle out of FATF’s grey list, in August,
2020, Pakistan has also banned around 88 terror groups and their leaders
including the names of Masood Azhar and Dawood Ibrahim.
A comprehensive National Action Plan was designed to
counter terrorism. Special Military Courts and Tribunals were also established
in Pakistan which convicted around 180 terrorists and announced verdicts in
additional than 300 terrorists-related matters by the highest of 2015.[11]
In May 2019, CTD was notified by the govt. as
investigation and prosecution agency to counter terrorism.
In July, 2020, Pakistan Senate una
nimously approved two bills to manage the financial situations and relevant offences as per instructions of FATF. In August, 2020, Parliament’s lower house also passed four bills concerning FATF implications. In September, the joint session of the Parliament amended around 15 laws to upgrade its system so on match international standards. These bills include
• The Islamabad Capital Territory Waqf Properties Bill, 2020
• The Anti-Money Laundering (Second Amendment) Bill, 2020”
• The Anti-Terrorism (Third Amendment) Bill, 2020
• The Surveying and Mapping (Amendment) Bill, 2020, to stop
and prohibiting printing, displaying, disseminating or using incorrect and
unofficial map of Pakistan
• The Islamabad supreme court (Amendment) Bill, 2019, Best Law College in Multan to
increase the quantity of judges in Islamabad supreme court for the efficacious
dispensation of justice
• Pakistan Medical Commission Bill, 2019
• The Medical Tribunal Bill, 2019
• The ICT Rights of Persons with Disability Bill, 2020
‘All-weather friend’ China supported Pakistan and
appreciated its counter-terrorism efforts and for being itself the victim of
terrorism for several decades. He extended his financial help of $1 billion as
loan to secure Pakistan from approaching to IMF.
During the watchdog’s plenary meeting of FATF in February,
2020, Pakistan needed three votes to avoid ‘blacklist’. The three most
influential members China, Best Law College in Multan Turkey and Malaysia voted in favor of Pakistan
saving Pakistan from being added to the ‘Blacklist’.[12]
Pakistan needs support of 12 out of 39 FATF members to
urge out of Grey List. Foreign Ministry of Pakistan is struggling hard in
obtaining the support at International level so as that it could achieve
escaping out of the grey list within subsequent meeting of FATF.
Conclusion
Pakistan is during a state of war against terrorism for
several years. during this war Pakistan possesses to tolerate multiple losses
including the sacrifices of civilians and personnel also as financial and
structural losses. Even then Pakistan possesses to face allegations and
criticism at international level for financing terrorism and prevailing
concealment .
1. https://bestlawcollegemultan.blogspot.com/2020/10/pakistan-law-college-plc-multan-courses.html
2. https://bestlawcollegemultan.blogspot.com/2020/10/ayan-law-college-multan.html
Nice blog! Very interesting and informative post….Thank's for sharing such a nice information….Keep it up!!!
ReplyDeletehttps://royaltaxi.pk/
Rent a Car from Islamabad
I am reading your post from the beginning, it was so interesting to read & I feel thanks to you for posting such a good blog, keep updates regularly.
ReplyDeleteProperty in Rawalpindi Islamabad
It is amazing and wonderful to visit your site.Thanks for sharing this information,this is useful to me.
ReplyDeleteWashing machine repairing services
Thanks for sharing such beautiful information with us. We hope you will share some more information about it. We really enjoy your blog & content
ReplyDeleteBlue World City Islamabad
This is an excellent article. Thank you for providing this information. Keep up the excellent work.
ReplyDeleteBest Schools in Lahore
Ilmi News
I really appreciate this post and I like this very much. I am waiting for new post here and Please keep it up in future
ReplyDeletewashing machine repair services in islamabad
"marriage bureau multan
ReplyDeletefree nikah service multan
onlnie marriage bureau multan
online rishta service multan
marriage services multan
"